Login
part of the imperfect parent family
Minor Topics Feed
MT Web

Education


Posted October 11th, 2007 by minortopics | Permalink

Illinois mandates “moment of silence” in schools

In a move critics call the first step down a slippery slope to prayer in schools, the Illinois House overrode a gubernatorial veto and put into law a state mandated “moment of silence” effective immediately:

The requirement, effective immediately, doesn’t contain any penalty for teachers who don’t adhere to the mandate. Nonetheless, the issue drew sharp ideological debate on the House floor, where critics said it was an incremental attempt to force prayer in schools.

“Let’s face it: That’s what this is about… to many who are pushing this,’” said Rep. Lou Lang, D-Skokie.

Proponents of the measure say it has nothing to do with religion, but is just meant to allow teachers and students to reflect on the coming school day.

“Our children today are bombarded by noise,” said Rep. Monique Davis, D-Chicago, a supporter of the measure. The idea of the legislation, she said, is “to just have a moment in a child’s life where he or she can be guaranteed a moment of silence. We don’t want to give them that?”

Ms. Davis, you’re not “giving” our children anything, you’re forcing it on them. I’m going to encourage my kids to spend that moment reading the First Amendment…


Information from: http://www.stltoday.com/stltoday/news/st...



Comments

5 Responses
  1. MM
    Oct 15th, 2007
    [1] | Flag |

    I think you’re wrong, no one’s mandating any particular religious view or anything. There’s nothing wrong with a moment of silence at the begining of the day so long as no one’s being forced to pray. I think you’re making way too much out of it.

  2. JessicaAvatar
    Oct 15th, 2007
    [2] | Flag |

    MM, I agree. If a kid wants to read the first amendment or sign along to Hannah Montana in their head, who’s to prevent them?

  3. prescott
    Oct 15th, 2007
    [3] | Flag |

    Come on, it clearly opens a back door towards prayer in school, and I’m not about to begin the erosion of personal rights no matter how trivial it might seem. An avalanche starts as one tiny snowflake, as my grandmother used to say.

    Or, as I’m pretending she used to say for the sake of this argument.

  4. CindyAvatar
    Jan 11th, 2008
    [4] | Flag |

    This is insane! Children are in school to be taught. Teaching comes in all shapes and sizes. Learning to BE QUIET at certain times is certainly one good lesson to learn. Many adults should have learned this technique years ago. What in the world is ‘wrong’ with a moment of silence? No one can invade your mind for 15 seconds and tell you what to think or feel. You can think about nothing, you can think about the homework you didn’t do (or did do), you can think about summer is only 5 months away… good grief! I’m an adult and taking classes at a local college… they start ever classes with a moment of silence — no hidden agenda… just a time to reflect, prepare for the class or whatever … Prayer is certainly an option, if you so desire, why not?

  5. Lea
    Mar 4th, 2008
    [5] | Flag |

    My son finished a sentence at the beginning of the moment of silence at school yesterday. He recieved no warning and has never been in trouble at school. He recieved a choice between 3 days in school suspension and Spending 8 hours on a Saturday at school sitting in a room silently. This has gone too far! I am furious. It seems to me that there are far more serious things to worry about w/ high schoolers. Is this some kind of power trip??

5 Responses
Leave a reply

Comment Preview
Active Education Discussions
Judge orders parents to vaccinate their children or go to jail8 comments
Girl stabbed in back with scissors at school1 comment
Vegan art teacher fired by school board5 comments
Kindergartners vote autistic boy off the island4 comments
Teacher says Jesus better than Santa Claus9 comments
Teen suspended for refusing to stand during Pledge of Allegiance1 comment
Connecticut teacher's hair set on fire3 comments
Student pees in lunch box, hands it to teacher2 comments
Substitute teacher fired for "wizardry"1 comment
Waukegan teacher charged with smoking pot in lounge1 comment
Advertisement
Recent Education News
Principal at "pregnancy pact" school res...
Girl "stabbed" on school bus
Teen writes "f*ck off" on exam, actually...
"Mean Girls" invade elementary school
Teen arrested for sending threatening em...
Seven cheer at graduation, get arrested
Teacher dies on last day of school
High school principal fired for plagiari...
Kindergartners vote autistic boy off the...
Student claims principal forced him to t...
» Read more Education news